Sugar is one of those ingredients that tends to stir up strong emotions in people, and as such, this infamous ingredient has many myths surrounding it. People like to blame it for everything from the obesity epidemic to type 2 diabetes to hyperactivity in children, but which of these prevailing myths are actually true?
- Myth: All sugar is bad for you.
Truth: Naturally occurring sugars found in fruits, vegetables, and dairy come with fiber, vitamins, and minerals. It’s the added sugars in processed foods that are linked to health issues when consumed in excess.
2. Myth: Sugar causes hyperactivity in children.
Truth: Despite popular belief, research has not found a consistent link between sugar intake and hyperactivity in kids. Excitement and other environmental factors often play a bigger role.
3. Myth: You should cut out all sugar to be healthy.
Truth: Total elimination isn’t necessary for most people. Moderation is key. A balanced diet can include occasional treats without harming health.
4. Myth: Brown sugar is healthier than white sugar.
Truth: Brown sugar contains a tiny amount of molasses, giving it a slightly different flavor and color, but nutritionally, it’s almost identical to white sugar.
5. Myth: Fruit is unhealthy because it has sugar.
Truth: Whole fruit is rich in fiber, antioxidants, and water—making its natural sugars digest more slowly and benefit your body.
6. Myth: Artificial sweeteners are a safe sugar alternative.
Truth: The safety of artificial sweeteners varies by type, and some may have metabolic effects or gut microbiome impacts still being studied. Natural alternatives like stevia or monk fruit may be better options for some.
7. Myth: Sugar is as addictive as cocaine.
Truth: While sugar can stimulate pleasure centers in the brain, equating it with drug addiction oversimplifies a complex behavioral and physiological relationship with food.
8. Myth: Sugar alone causes obesity.
Truth: Obesity results from a consistent calorie surplus—eating more energy than your body uses—not from sugar alone. However, sugar-sweetened foods and beverages are calorie-dense and easy to overconsume, which can contribute to weight gain. It’s not sugar by itself, but excessive calories (especially from ultra-processed foods) combined with low physical activity that drive obesity.
9. Myth: Eating sugar directly causes type 2 diabetes.
Truth: Sugar does not directly cause type 2 diabetes. The real issue is insulin resistance, which develops over time due to factors like genetics, obesity, inactivity, and chronic poor diet. However, diets high in added sugars—especially from sugary drinks—can increase risk by promoting weight gain and impairing insulin sensitivity. The link is indirect but important.
Sugar isn’t inherently evil and making it the scapegoat for so many issues doesn’t really address these concerns adequately. In moderation and within a nutrient-dense diet, sugar isn’t harmful, but when it becomes a staple rather than a treat, it can negatively impact health.
Copyright 2025, GoHealthier.com
